Wednesday, August 20, 2008

Stay Away from Harrold

The New York Times was reporting yesterday that today might be the day that Obama announces his pick for vice president. Of course, other papers were saying Friday and everyone is looking for something to talk about whether it's true or not. It's just the way the 24 hour news cycle goes during the dead month of August. So we'll see what happens. I'm not exactly holding my breath on this one.

Also, is anyone else ready for August to be over? It's like a news wasteland. Bring on the action.

In the meantime, I have to point your attention to the small town of Harrold, Texas, which, starting this month, will allow their teachers to bring concealed firearms to school. That's right. Guns and schools, together at last. After all, nothing limits violence quite like having more guns around.

Maybe I'm getting used to the liberal, eastern, latte-sipping lifestyle but that's just nuts. Admittedly, there were more than a few points during my career as a middle school teacher that I can't say I really would have minded having a concealed firearm handy, but that's probably an argument against letting me have one.

I mean, here in New York there are people upset because the NYPD runs the school safety officers and they worry about that.

According to school superintendent David Thweatt, "When the federal government started making schools gun-free zones, that's when all of these shootings started."

Wait. When were schools not gun-free? I love these lone ranger types who stand up to the federal government for freedom and safety by doing things like putting guns in classrooms with children.

Anyway, the takeaway from all this is that August is boring and don't send your kids to school in Harrold, Texas.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Try a Little Thoughtfulness

Here's a pretty good column breaking down what exactly we saw at the candidate forum with Rick Warren over the weekend. Most of the professional pundits (and a good portion of the amateurs) seem to be saying that McCain came out on top of that one. While Obama wandered, McCain focused and gave personal, gut-feeling answers.

In one sense, that's exactly what happened. McCain's answers were significantly punchier than Obama's more professorial ruminations on the questions posed to him. The pundits all took that to mean that Obama lost and McCain won. I'm not so sure. At least, I'm not so sure that's the way things should be.

The fact is, we live in a very complicated world. Complex questions don't always have simple answers. Sometimes, in fact, giving simple answers is a disservice to the issue at hand. Take the war in Iraq. There are a variety of reasons - both good and bad - for our entering into the war and there are a variety of reasons - again, both good and bad - for getting out now. When looking at all of the different factors in play, I'm not sure if I want someone who offers a four word response to that issue. I think I would much prefer to have someone who has shown that they've thought through the issues and understand the nuances.

We've had eight years of gut feeling leadership. Maybe now it's time to try thoughtfulness.

Monday, August 18, 2008

The News in Pakistan

Barring some major development in the presidential race or another Brittney Spears sighting, it's likely that the big news of the day (and maybe even tomorrow) is going to be the resignation of Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf. This didn't exactly come out of the blue. The opposition party in the Parliment has been working to impeach him and his popularity in his country has dropped dramatically. Still, it's a pretty big deal.

I don't know much about Pakistan or what the real conditions/possibilities/opportunities there are at this point. I do know that it's a country pretty important to our interests and that it's very much in our interests to have that country as stable as possible. The last thing we need is another Muslim country in the region becoming unstable and have it turn into a breeding ground for still more terrorists.

One thing that struck me as interesting is how democratic the whole thing is taking place, especially given that Musharraf took power in a military coup. True, it was a bloodless coup (as the press keeps pointing out), but a coup is a coup. Now under pressure from the popularly elected parliment, the president is resigning in an orderly way, apparently without using the military for some sort of desperation power play. The next few days and weeks will make things more clear, but I think that's an encouraging sign.

Friday, August 15, 2008

The State of Affairs

Barack Obama has a new ad out that seems to be responding to McCain's celebrity ads. The gist of the ad is the old childhood retort: "I know you are, but what am I?" The ad shows clips of McCain on David Letterman, the View, SNL, and other shows. There's also clips of him being hugged by George Bush (which I think should appear in every Obama ad). It's not a bad ad in that it points out the hypocrisy of McCain's campaign, but I don't think it's a very good ad either. The problem with it is that it cedes the terms of the debate to McCain. Now the ad wars are about who's the bigger celebrity. That's ridiculous. It was silly when McCain did it and it's just as silly now that Obama's doing it.

As Joe Klein points out in this excellent column, there is a very real choice before voters this year that has nothing to do with who has been on TV more. McCain and Obama offer starkly contrasting views on foreign policy, domestic policy, economic policy, and any other kind of policy that there is. This is a real election about where we want to go as a country. At least, it could be a real election about where we want to go as a country. We just aren't getting that right now. Instead we're getting a comprehensive debate that boils down to "You're a celebrity!" "No, you're a celebrity!" "No, you're a celebrity!" "No, you are!" It makes me sad.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Tom Cruise at the Olympics

I've got the Olympic fever. You know, the kind where you find yourself sitting in front of the TV shouting things at athletes competing in sports you didn't actually know existed. At least, that's how I've been spending my evenings.

It was while I was watching swimming coverage last night that a slightly more political thought occurred to me. Namely, that the Tom Cruise Effect was in full force. I've written about this a couple of times before. The gist of the effect is that no matter what happens, the media will fit it into a particular established narrative (e.g. Tom Cruise is crazy). No matter what happens, the event will get shoehorned into whatever narrative the media is telling at the time.

That's what brings me to the Olympics. I'm not sure if you've noticed, but Michael Phelps is kind of a big deal. He already has more gold medals than anyone else in history and he's shooting to break the record for most gold medals at a single Olympic games. This is undeniably a historic undertaking and in responses, the press has made pretty much the whole Olympics (at least in the Cube) about Phelps.

So last night I was watching an interview with Jason Lezak. A few days ago he swam the anchor leg in the 4x100 freestyle relay. (Michael Phelps was also on that team.) Behind by nearly an entire body length with only about 25 meters to go, Lezak caught up to the French anchor and out touched him at the wall to win the race. It was an incredible feat of swimming, it set the world record, the drama was incredible, and all the press could talk about is how it relates to Michael Phelps. During the interview I saw last night the reporter was talking about how Lezak's swim helped Phelps. Lezak took it in stride, but also very clearly wanted to make it known that he was a swimmer too who'd just earned a gold medal. Not that it mattered for much in the eyes of the media.

Also, check out this story. It's a story about a French swimmer winning a gold medal, but by the end it's turned to Michael Phelps.

Don't get me wrong, I like Michael Phelps a lot and I'm glad he's on our side. I think he's also a great example of how the press always falls victim to the Tom Cruise Effect, no matter what's being covered.

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

All Sizzle, No Steak

I think that for the most part Obama has been unfairly painted as being flush with style but short on substance. From issue to issue he has well considered positions and - if the latest round of ads is any indication - seems to have a much better focus on issues that McCain does.

That being said, the Obama campaign's announcement that they will be notifying supporters directly about Obama's choice for VP struck me as all steak and no sizzle. It seems like an awful lot of hype for something that isn't all that noteworthy.

I get that the intention is to show that the people are directly the ones who matter in this race. It's not about the press or the elite. It's about the regular folks who've been giving their $25 dollars. Okay, I see that. What I don't see is how much of a difference this makes. CNN will have the news on the air about 30 seconds after the e-mail goes out. All the papers will have it in their online editions about two minutes after that. So what's really the point?

I guess the point is that it makes a statement. It's a symbol. I get that. I do. I just don't think it matters that much.

P.S. I think he's going to pick Bayh.

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

The Contrast

Whatever you were planning on doing right now, you should stop and watch this video. Seriously. The music and some of the visuals are a little overdone/melodramatic, but it's scary. It's called Republicans and Military Men on John McCain. The gist is that McCain's first instinct is always to rely on force. He's beligerent. In the words of Pat Buchanan in the video, "There's no doubt John McCain is going to be a war president. Can anybody see John McCain as kind of a peace time, Calvin Coolidge president?"

The answer is no. I can't see that. And that scares me a lot. So watch this video. After you see it, you may find yourself wanting to visit this site too.

In the interests of bringing balance to this post, here's the latest anti-Obama ad. How's that for a contrast?