Showing posts with label unspeak. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unspeak. Show all posts

Monday, February 8, 2010

Unspeak in the New Yorker

I know that it's about a month old at this point, but I'm finally caught up on my New Yorker reading so I've finally had a chance to read the profile of Arne Duncan. On the whole, I thought it was pretty interesting and encapsulated a lot of my ambivalence about the guy and his agenda. Some things I'm totally on board with. Others, less so.

What I'm totally opposed to, though, is the kind of ridiculous journalism that slips in lines like, "In the fight over education in America today, there, roughly speaking, two major camps: free-market reformers, who believe that competition, choice, and incentives must have a greater part in education; and liberal traditionalists who rally around teachers’ unions and education schools." (For the record, that's the author of the article, not Duncan speaking.)

In other words, there are people who want to help kids learn through a competition-based reform model and there are people who are union-loving, education-school-promoting, failing-school-allowing defenders of the status quo. At least with the "roughly speaking" phrase there's the chance that some other camps might exist.

I've written about this before, but it doesn't make me any less angry to see. School reform doesn't necessarily mean charter schools and teacher incentive pay. It just doesn't. It can also mean reducing class sizes, reworking curriculum, promoting the community school model, and a host of other efforts taking place across the country. For whatever reason, our journalists just can't seem to wrap their minds around the fact that there could be a whole lot of different reform ideas out there and that people who don't think charter schools are the answer might not be in favor of keeping everything exactly the same.

Unspeak lives, even in the pages of the New Yorker.

Wednesday, October 28, 2009

Dumbing in Des Moines

Regular readers may know that I'm not exactly Mr. Get-Tough-Raise-the-Standards-No-Excuses and that I think the phrase "dumbing down" is really just so much unspeak. But every so often, I see something that makes me think that the phrase may have some use after all. Take Des Moines. Please.

Seriously, though, the Des Moines public schools are considering reducing the number of credits needed to graduate in order to try to reduce the high school dropout rate. While reducing the drop-out rate is a laudable goal, I find myself questioning this particular method of doing so. Let's play a little bit of best case/worst case.

Best case, the school board has realized that their requirements are unrealistic/unreasonable and don't actually promote student learning. As such, they are adjusting the criteria for graduation to better reflect the needs of the students. Let's hope that's what is happening.

Worst case, the board has forgotten that a high school diploma does not have any real intrinsic worth and is using it as a replacement for actual learning. If the standards really are being dumbed down in order to ensure that more kids get a slip of paper saying they've graduated high school, it's a huge mistake. The slip of paper doesn't actually prepare you for the job. All the paper does is signify that you've done the work and learning needed to be successful beyond school. Raising graduation rates only means something if being a graduate means something. If everyone gets a diploma regardless of how much they've done or know, then what use is the diploma?

Truly, we are facing a drop out crisis across the country that needs to be addressed. But let's focus on early interventions, academic help, and things like that rather than making graduation easier. Dumbing down graduation standards doesn't actually help anyone. If that's the strategy, Des Moines might not be worth taking at all.

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Where's the Middle Ground and Outrage?

Do you ever get the feeling that we're missing the middle ground when we have educational debates? I do sometimes. It seems like two camps stake out diametrically opposed positions and miss the fact that there's probably a significant amount of common ground in between.

Take promotional requirements for example. In Memphis, the city schools have banned flunking (and then retaining) students in pre-kindergarten through third grade. (If you really read the article it's not quite as touchy feely as it sounds.) Then, in New York City, the Mayor (with his recently renewed control of the schools) is looking to end - unspeak alert! - social promotion in fourth and sixth grade.

It seems like there should be a middle ground here between never retaining a child and always retaining children if they don't meet standardized test score cut offs. What about looking at each child on a case by case basis and determining what's best for that child? Sometimes it may be retention. Other times it may be promotion with heavy interventions and extra help. This all or nothing, black and white stuff just wears a little thin.

Of course, if a child can't pass the standardized tests in New York, maybe they do deserve to be retained. As reported by Gotham Schools last week, the scoring of the ELA test is done in such a way that a student who knew nothing and guessed randomly would likely (57%) pass the test with a level two.

Have I mentioned before that "accountability" definitely falls into that unspeak buzzword bin?

Let's just stop a moment and consider this information, though, because I think it's really stunning. We're basing a whole system - promotional criteria, curriculum, data systems, school report cards, mayoral campaigns, etc - around test scores that are supposed to measure what students know and how much they're learning. But the tests may be beaten by a student who randomly guesses all their answers! I know I've been out of town for the last two weeks, so maybe I missed it, but shouldn't there be outrage about this?

Oy. It's good to be back.

Friday, July 17, 2009

Unspeak Bonanza

Well, it's Friday and the Daily News has come through with an educational unspeak bonanza. Unspeak, you may recall, is the art of making an argument without actually making an argument. It's about picking language that seeks to preclude any disagreement (think "support the middle class," whatever that means). Education is chock full of unspeak and the Daily News tapped into the motherlode this week.

In the article, "test experts" say that the tests being given to city kids are getting easier, which means more kids are passing and moving on to the next grade. In other words, standards are being dumbed down to undermine accountability and that's leading to social promotion. Holy unspeak!

Frankly, I don't habe the background or the data in front of me to agree or disagree with the claims. DOE says that the tests have gotten harder so they're requiring fewer correct answers to show proficiency. Critics say that it's a game to make the schools look better and reflect more favorably on the Mayor (juking the stats, as they'd say in The Wire).

That said, it sure does look bad. According to the story, on this year's test kids needed to answer 28% of questions correctly to be judged proficient. When you remember that these are multiple choice tests with four possible answers (and thus someone who guesses randomly on every question should figure on answering 25% of the questions correctly) that seems pretty low. A slilghtly lucky kid could simply guess his way to proficiency.

I guess the real question here is whether standardized testing is really the best way to assess standards. Unspeak though they may be, I agree that there needs to be some baseline of what kids should learn in school. I just doubt the bubble filling and all the drama and juking that comes with it is really the best way.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Agreeing into Oblivion

Al Sharpton and Newt Gingrich are working together now. At least for a while. In other news, hell has frozen over.

Seriously, though, last Saturday uber-liberal Al Sharpton and arch-conservative Newt Gingrich shared the stage at a rally calling for the closing of the achivement gap. Sharpton called the pairing the "original odd couple" which would be a pretty good line if he hadn't already used it to describe himself and New York City schools chancellor Joel Klein.

On the one hand, this is great news. It means that leaders, regardless of political affiliation, are seeing that the achievement gap is a problem that demands a solution. On the other hand, this level of ubiquitous agreement doesn't necessarily mean that we're going to get results. Just ask anyone who wants to "protect the middle class" or "support our troops." Everyone agrees that these are good things. Being against them would pretty much be akin to opposing motherhood. But agreeing on the goal doesn't make the fight over achieving the goal any easier.

The danger here is that "close the achievement gap" is going to be agreed into oblivion. It'll just become another bromide that gets thrown out around campaign time. It becomes just another example of unspeak. What we need is not rallies saying that we're against the achievement gap (or for the middle class or in favor of motherhood), but real solutions to how we're actually going to get something done.

At the rally, Gingrich said, "We're not telling you what the answer is." No kidding. But until we do find the solution, all the rallies in the world aren't going to help.

Friday, May 8, 2009

The Problem With Education

In my very first post on this blog, I wrote that one of the biggest problems with education is that no one knows what the problem with education is. We all kind of have the sense that the schools aren't educating kids as well as they should be and we know that the data shows this is particularly bad for poor children and children of color. But what's actually the problem? No standards or overly rigid curriculum? Bad teachers or administrative micro-managing? Uninvolved parents or lack of choices? The list goes on and on and on. Because we can't even come to a consensus on where the problems lies, we're even more fractured when it comes to finding a solution.

As Dan Brown summarizes on the Huffington Post, Ronald Wolk has written a pretty comprehensive look at what he sees as the major misdiagnoses that have been made since A Nation at Risk was published 25 years ago. Obviously Wolk's perspective on this is subject to debate. That's the whole point of the first paragraph of today's post. However, I tend to think that he may be onto something here.

It's really worth reading Brown's summary of not Wolk's entire piece. I won't do too much re-capping here. What I will say is that if I had to reduce it all to one sentence, it would be this: We've let ideology trump reality time and again in our educational thinking.

We say that we need to find exceptional teachers for every classroom. That's great, but every one of the millions of teachers in this country can't be an exception. We need to make sure that every teacher has the tools and support they need to be a good teacher. Not everyone can be Jamie Escalante.

We say that we just need to increase standards and kids will meet them. Right. Shouldn't we find better ways to reach them rather than just shout "LEARN!" at them.

We've become so obsessed with accountability that we've forgotten that tests should measure learning rather than learning being designed to ensure test success.

We've become so caught up in the education unspeak - Standards! Accountability! Ending Social Promotion! Choice! - that we've forgotten to keep looking at what's actually working.

A Nation at Risk pointed a bright light at education and said, "fix this." Twenty five years later, I don't know that we're any closer to figuring out how.

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

Educational Unspeak

I've mentioned the notion of unspeak in several previous posts, but never really expounded on the topic. The concept is fairly simple. Often, it's referred to as framing an issue. That is, casting the language of the debate in the way that is most favorable to your side. (You can read a column by Jack Shafer on unspeak here.)

Another way to conceptualize unspeak is that it's a method for making covert arguments in addition to the overt arguments you make. The classic example here is the abortion debate where you have pro-life debating pro-choice. While the actual arguments revolve around abortion, there are also covert arguments at work. Anyone supporting abortion must not be pro-life, which makes them pro-death? Same with people who are not pro-choice. They must be in favor of total state control over every decision. Obviously, neither of these is true, but that's the beauty of unspeak. It allows implication without ever actually making the argument. The other advantage if unspeak is that it allows you to place yourself in a virtually unassailable position. Who is honestly going to argue against life? When used truly effectively (and insidiously), unspeak is a way to preclude debate before it even begins.

The world of politics is most fraught with unspeak, but education, particularly education policy has its fair share as well. What follows is a (far from complete) list of the particularly gratuitous unspeak we encounter every day as we address educational issues.

Standards. We hear about it all the time. Kids need to meet the standards. What's missed in all of this talk, though, is that standards are anything but. We don't have any system of national standards in this country so the standards for each state are different from the standards of every other state. Not to make the point too obvious here, but if it's different it's not standard. Even within states there are key concepts that are assigned to grade levels (and labeled standards), but the level of proficiency required in those concepts varies widely from year to year. We don't have a standards system for comparison between states or between years within a state. Efforts are being made in the right direction and we're certainly better in this regard than we were 25 years ago. However, focusing on standards as a monolithic concept is misleading and implies greater uniformity than actually exists.

Accountability. Who could argue against accountability? You do what you do and accept the consequences (be they positive or negative) for what you've done. It's so basic and appealing that it's hard to argue against. Of course, in the educational world, accountability is a code word for punishment for not meeting "standards" (see above). Because of the way the system is structured we don't really hold kids accountable in any meaningful sense for the learning the do or don't do over the course of the year. But again, who can argue against it? Because accountability is such a powerful concept, a host of less desireable elements (e.g. constant high stakes testing) get brought in under the same umbrella.

Dumbing down. As test scores rise, so do the chorus of naysayers who claim that the tests have been "dumbed down" in order to make the tests easier to pass. Dumbing down is indisputably a bad thing. However, it's not always clear that's what's happening. I read an article several months ago (sorry, no link) saying that in New York the fourth grade reading test used to contain passages at an eighth grade level but that the test had been "dumbed down" so that the passages were now at only a fifth grade level. Is that really a bad thing? How reasonable was it to expect fourth graders to read at an eighth grade level? The test was reasonably adjusted to provide a more accurate gauge for how kids are performing. The provoked howls of rage from the anti-dumbing crowd, but if we're serious about "standards" and then holding kids "accountable" we ought to make sure that what we're doing makes sense.

Social promotion. Assuming that the test isn't "dumbed down" and a kid doesn't meet the "standards", how do we hold them "accountable." Well, at least in New York, we hold the kid back a year (or retain them in the gentler vocabulary). This is because the Mayor and the Chancellor have ended social promotion, which sounds like some sort of Communist self-esteem booster. You're going to have a hard time finding someone who will argue for social promotion because it definitionally precludes the notion that outside of self-esteem or a child's social well-being there's any reason for a child to be promoted who doesn't meet the "standards." This of course ignores the fact that there's no demonstrated educational benefit to making a child repeat a grade. But this isn't a debate we can have because unspeak has effectively decided the issue already.

Those are four examples that immediately come to mind for me. I'll be curious to hear any additional examples of educational unspeak that you can come up with.