WARNING: This post may contain observations that run counter to conventional wisdom. Don't say you weren't warned.
The trendy thing among a certain school of school reformers lately has been to point to New Orleans post-Katrina as a model of education reform.
Newsweek writes that "New Orleans has made more educational progress than any other city, largely because the public-school system was wiped out." Arne Duncan said that Hurricane Katrina was "the best thing that happened to the education system in New Orleans." The conventional wisdom says that with the New Orleans school system (and much of the city) destroyed, reformers were able to start from scratch and put in a system based on what we know works for kids. And just look at the results.
Let's look at those results for a moment. An article in the Houston Chronicle this week highlights a study that finds that Katrina kids are doing better than their Texas counterparts. In Texas. That's right, Texas. Not New Orleans. It seems that the kids who relocated to Texas after the hurricane and stayed there are doing better in the Texas school system than the kids from Texas in the Texas school system.
Here's where your conventional wisdom gets challenged. If the reason kids are doing so much better now in New Orleans is that the school system has been completely reformed, why are kids also excelling in Texas? Let's grant for the sake of argument that the New Orleans schools were terrible before Katrina. So obviously there's a lot of room for improvement with these kids. But if it's the brilliant new system that's doing it, why are the kids in Texas also making such gains? Maybe I'm missing something, but I don't often see Houston hailed as the brightest star in the education reform firmament.
Now, I'm perfectly willing to believe that there's a rational explanation that will keep the conventional wisdom intact. I know that reading a summary of research from the Texas Education Agency in the Houston Chronicle is not exactly top notch research. But I do think we need to consider all the data when we're making grand pronouncements. And I just don't quite see how this fits the narrative.
Showing posts with label New Orleans. Show all posts
Showing posts with label New Orleans. Show all posts
Friday, April 9, 2010
Friday, March 6, 2009
Charter World
NPR just ran a pretty interesting story about the massive charter school experiment going on in New Orleans. According to the story, more than half of New Orleans kids attend charter schools. That massive number doesn't do anything, though, to change what seem to be the recurring story lines anywhere charter schools exist. Proponents point out that the charters outperform the traditional public schools. Opponents argue that the charters aren't serving special education kids (they have half the numbers) and are pushing their "problem kids" into the public system. Sound familiar?
Here's what makes New Orleans so fascinating to follow, though. In addition to the already huge number of kids in the charter programs, NPR says the number is growing and the state superintendent of education says that he can envision a future in which all New Orleans children attend charter schools. And that's where it's really going to get interesting.
Charter school opponents argue that one of the fundamental reasons for their success is the inherent self-selection that goes into the charter school process. Even if schools are not intentionally "creaming" their students, it's hard to completely avoid simply based on the way that admissions are done at these schools. But what happens when all schools are charters? If/when that happens in New Orleans there will be no public schools that the charters would be able to push (or be accused of pushing) those problem children into. Then what?
If the schools are still successful and test scores and other measures continue to rise, then we really need to look at charters as a possibility for wider use. (The New Orleans prolilferation would also answer a lot of questions about the scalability of charters.) If, however, once all kids are in the charter system those schools may begin to resemble the current traditional school structure where some schools succeed and others don't.
While the results of this experiment are far from clear at this point, New Orleans should definitely be on the radar of charter proponents and opponents. One way or another, a lot of our questions are going to be answered.
Here's what makes New Orleans so fascinating to follow, though. In addition to the already huge number of kids in the charter programs, NPR says the number is growing and the state superintendent of education says that he can envision a future in which all New Orleans children attend charter schools. And that's where it's really going to get interesting.
Charter school opponents argue that one of the fundamental reasons for their success is the inherent self-selection that goes into the charter school process. Even if schools are not intentionally "creaming" their students, it's hard to completely avoid simply based on the way that admissions are done at these schools. But what happens when all schools are charters? If/when that happens in New Orleans there will be no public schools that the charters would be able to push (or be accused of pushing) those problem children into. Then what?
If the schools are still successful and test scores and other measures continue to rise, then we really need to look at charters as a possibility for wider use. (The New Orleans prolilferation would also answer a lot of questions about the scalability of charters.) If, however, once all kids are in the charter system those schools may begin to resemble the current traditional school structure where some schools succeed and others don't.
While the results of this experiment are far from clear at this point, New Orleans should definitely be on the radar of charter proponents and opponents. One way or another, a lot of our questions are going to be answered.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)